
WWW.THECOLLECTOR.COM
Soviet Show Trials: A Grueling History of Repression
In the USSR during Stalins regime, show trials were a tool of political repression. The trials were orchestrated events that coerced confessions out of innocent people. The end was to consolidate Stalins power by removing any potential rivals. The Great Purge of the 1930s was the most brutal political cleansing event in which up to 1.5 million people were arrested, interrogated, and tortured; up to 1.2 million of them diedeither by execution or in a forced labor camp called a Gulag.What Is a Show Trial?Joseph Stalin, Secretary-General of the Communist Party of Soviet Russia, 1942. Source: Wikimedia CommonsCommunist show trials were a central part of the Stalinist regime in the USSR. They were essentially theatrical productions in which the judge and jury had both already decided that the defendant was guilty, and they did not consult evidence before issuing their verdict. The victims of the show trials were sometimes coached on what to say before going to the stand to ensure that everybody followed the same story, like a script.These performances often went above and beyond. For example, if the defendant were accused of being an enemy spy, the prosecutors would bring his mother or wife in for an interrogation. They would tell the woman that the accused had already confessed to the crimes when he had not. She was then required to testify that she knew he had been a spy all along and had committed crimes against the state, and she would agree because it was no use fighting with the truth if he had confessed.The prosecutors would then tell the man that his wife/mother had said to them that he had committed the crime and that she was going to testify as a witness, so he might as well just confess. To get him to agree to lie on the stand, they might offer immunity for his family or take the death penalty off the table, but they were under no moral obligation to keep their word.Why Would They Fake a Trial?Donetsk repressii by Andrew Butko, 2007. Source: Wikimedia CommonsShow trials originated during the Great Purge of the 1930s, and they were to eliminate anybody who challenged Joseph Stalin or the regime. The catalyst for the political purge was the 1934 assassination of Sergei Kirov, a Bolshevik revolutionary from the 1917 Russian Revolution.Whether or not Stalin played a role in the assassination is debatable. Still, ultimately, he used Kirovs death to ask the Politburo (the policymaking committee) for permission to cleanse the government of anybody who might betray the USSR or Stalin himself. The NKVD (the secret police) began arresting the so-called enemies, including Trotskyitessomeone who associated with or favored Leon Trotsky, a man who challenged Stalin.The crowded gallery of a show trial where those accused of crimes against the state in the Soviet Union or Nazi Germany were tried without fair defense. Source: FriezePolitical repression, show trials, and gulags were an open secret; the public attended the trials, and details of the proceedings were published both within and outside of the USSR. Stalin desperately needed to prove that there were enemies of the state, and foreign agents, or Western spies who posed a threat to the USSR and Stalin himself. He wished to jail or kill all potential political rivals before they could challenge him.Stalin and the rest of the communists throughout the USSR and their satellite states would continue the tradition of denouncing their rivals for decades.The Great PurgeMemorial to the Victims of Political Repression by Vyacheslav Bukharov, 2021. Source: Wikimedia CommonsThe Great Purge, sometimes called the Great Terror, should not be confused with the Red Terror, a period of political repression from 1918 to 1922 after the 1917 Revolution. The Red Terror was orchestrated by the Cheka (the first Soviet secret police, later the NKVD, and even later, it would be called the KGB) and the Bolsheviks, resulting in the deaths of up to 600,000 people.This era of political cleansing lasted from 1936 to 1938, but its most prolific year was 1937; overall, upwards of 1.5 million people were arrested, and at least 681,692 people were found guilty and executed, and another 116,000 people died in the Gulagsofficially. It is estimated that upwards of 1.2 million people died, but deaths in Gulags often went unreported.The 1930s Great Purge was the systematic mass murder of political opponents. Although the United Nations Genocide Convention does not include political killings in the definition of genocide, many academics have called the purge a political genocide. They did not just target politicians, though; they also went for Red Army leadership, kulaks (considered wealthy peasants), religious leaders, scientists, doctors, intelligentsia, ethnic minorities, and anybody else who may have been standing in the wrong place at the wrong time. People were imprisoned or sent to Gulags to serve sentences of performing hard labor for the crime of telling jokes or of writing poemsand repression of the arts is still present in Russia today.The Gulag SystemGulag location map by NordNordWest, 2015. Source: Wikimedia CommonsThe USSR has a long history of genocide and ethnic cleansing operations, and the Great Purge is just one example.Victims of the Purge were sent to a Gulag if they were not executed outright. Gulag, sometimes written as GULAG, is an acronym for Main Directorate of Correctional Labor Camps. It was a vast network of forced labor camps and prisons in the Soviet Union. Labor camps began in 1919 with an official decree on April 15, but the Gulag system was established in 1930 and was not officially abolished until 1960.It is estimated that 18 million people passed through 53 camps and 423 labor colonies (camps where prisoners were forced to work in heavy industries such as mining, logging, and construction). Official estimates are always lower, but somewhere between 2.3 and 17.6 million prisoners lost their lives (Predota). The Soviets hid, or never made, records, and bodies of prisoners who died in the Gulags were buried in mass graves and never spoken of again. Many thousands of families still have no idea when their loved ones died nor where they were buried.One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich (1962) is a novel by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, a Russian who wished to tell the world what life was like in the USSR. The namesake, Ivan, was an inmate in the prison camp system after he was falsely convicted of being a spy. Solzhenitsyn has written several nonfiction books on the USSR and the Gulags, but his novel was the first of its kind.Memorial to the Victims of Political Repressions in the suburbs of Yekaterinburg by Vyacheslav Bukharov, 2021. Source: Wikimedia CommonsThe Soviet forced labor camps were akin to Nazi labor camps and operated during the same time. Before the Nazis even began relocating people, the Soviets began transporting people via cattle car in the 1930s to labor camps and relocation camps. They also invented mobile gas units to kill their prisoners in the 1930s. Then the Nazis took the idea to connect a trucks exhaust pipe to an enclosed space to gas prisoners inside.Prisoners in Soviet camps often died of starvation, executions, harsh working conditions, or extreme cold in the camps of Siberia. Roughly two-thirds of Russia is covered in permafrost, which never thaws, and they have vast deposits of natural resources such as coal, natural gas, and rocks and minerals. The Soviets used prisoners to perform the hard labor of extracting these resources to (literally) fuel their economy.Wall of sorrow at the first exhibition of the victims of Stalinism in Moscow by Dmitry Borko, 1988. Source: Wikimedia CommonsMass graves of victims are still being excavated today, such as the Kommunarkashooting grounds near Moscow, where over 6,600 bodies have been discovered. Sites have been uncovered throughout the USSR, such as in Ukraine, where there are now several memorials to pay tribute to the victims. In 2021, construction workers in Odesa, Ukraine, found at least 20,000 corpses buried in a mass grave. In Kurapaty, Belarus, in a forest outside Minsk, at least 30,000 but up to 250,000 people were killed by the Soviets and buried in mass graves.Adam Hochschild traveled through Russia, interviewing people, studying archives, and visiting former camp locations to write the book The Unquiet Ghost: Russians Remember Stalin (2003). He describes how mass graves were frequently discovered in the USSR and just as soon covered up. A tunnel in the Ural Mountains of western Russia was discovered with thousands of bodies in it, and a mass grave of more than a thousand bodies was uncovered after severe flooding in Kolpashevo, Russia.Eliminating the IntelligentsiaVsevolod Meyerhold 2024 stamp of Russia. Source: Wikimedia CommonsOne of the main purposes of the Purge of the 1930s and show trials was to eliminate political opponents, but they also went after common folk and academicsotherwise called the intelligentsia. The Soviets called them the bourgeoisie, a middle class of educated, wealthy people whom the Soviets believed represented the ruling elite of the former Russian Empire; therefore, they were enemies of the communist state.Actor, director, and theater producer Vsevolod Meyerhold was arrested during the period of cleansing for being a formalistone who adhered to a literary theory called Russian Formalism. Under Stalin, this literary movement became an all-encompassing term for anything considered elitist art, not just literature, that contradicted Soviet Socialist Realism, a more traditional, figurative form of art. Thus, Formalists were seen as enemies during Stalins reign because they would not adhere to the new way of life and art, which differed from the avant-garde art of the early USSR.Meyerhold was arrested in June 1939. His wife was stabbed to death by home invaders, and he was tortured mercilessly by the secret police in Moscow, where he confessed to being a spy for Britain and Japan. He, like hundreds of thousands of others, confessed to a crime he did not commit so that the torture would end. After confessing, he was executed on February 1, 1940. In 1955, the Soviet Supreme Court absolved him of the charges, but it was too little too late.The Khrushchev Thaw and Political RehabilitationThe Soviet Union 1963 CPA 2824 stamp (Russian Civil War Hero Marshal of the Soviet Union Mikhail Tukhachevsky. Source: Wikimedia CommonsThe Khrushchev Thaw was a period of relaxation and a reversal of the repression caused during the Stalin years. Nikita Khrushchev, who held several government positions, including Prime Minister and First Secretary of the Communist Party, was highly critical of Stalin and made it a mission to rehabilitate/exonerate victims of the Purge (and other subsequent small pogroms or political repression).The above images of Russian stamps with photos of Meyerhold and Mikhail Tukhachevsky were part of a series of stamps commemorating victims of the repression. Tukhachevskywas a prominent military general, and just after he was demoted to commander of the Volga Military District, he was arrested in 1937. He was tortured and interrogated, and he made a false confession to being a German spy, and he was executed less than a month later.Stalin and the other prominent communists knew that victims would confess to just about anything if the circumstances were rightand the circumstances had to be torture.ReferencesHochschild, Adam. (2003). The Unquiet Ghost: Russians Remember Stalin. Mariner Books.Kovago, Jozsef. (1959). You Are All Alone. Praeger.Mertz, Dawn-Eve. (2024). Young Men Go West: The Hungarian Revolution of 1956 and One Teenagers Risky Escape. Kleo Press.Rayfield, Donald. (2004). Stalin and his Hangmen. Random House.Sebag Montefiore, Simon. (2003).Stalin: The Court of the Red Tsar. Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
0 Σχόλια
0 Μοιράστηκε
8 Views