The Best Sweet Treat First-Time Aldi Shoppers Should Never Skip

Joni Hanebutt/Shutterstock

If you're new to Aldi, we have a sweet tidbit of advice: Don't check out before checking out the desserts — there's a certain type of cheesecake you won't want to miss. Cheesecake has a way of turning even the most ordinary moment into something worth savoring. One bite can feel as festive as a birthday, as comforting as a Sunday dinner, or as spontaneous as a late-night snack straight from the fridge. Aldi makes it easy to bring a little spark of celebration home with its Bake Shop Cheesecake Sampler — a 16-ounce, ready-to-serve dessert that costs less than $6 and should be in your kitchen right now. 

The sampler includes eight slices spread across four popular flavors, so everyone can grab a favorite — or better yet, try a little of each. The classic New York style is creamy, smooth, and satisfyingly simple. The strawberry swirl adds brightness with a ribbon of fruit running through the custardy base, offering just the right tang to balance the richness. The triple chocolate tilts toward decadence, blending cocoa into multiple layers. And the turtle cheesecake features caramel, chocolate chips, and chopped pecans for a salty-sweet crunch.

Convenience is a key reason shoppers love Aldi's Bake Shop Cheesecake Sampler. Since it comes pre-sliced, it moves seamlessly from fridge to table — no prep, no fuss, no worry about uneven knife cuts. The mix of practicality and variety has earned plenty of praise. On the Aldi subreddit, r/Impossibly_me wrote, "I loved the chocolate and turtle ones, but the whole variety pack was delicious!" While a few note it's not quite on par with a high-end bakery cheesecake, most agree it punches above its weight in flavor and value. As r/Nhadalie summed it up, "It isn't comparable to homemade. But it's a good deal compared to frozen or store-bought cheesecakes."

Ultimately, the Bake Shop Cheesecake Sampler reflects what Aldi does best: turning affordable products into little luxuries. Whether you're hosting a lively get-together or enjoying a quiet slice at home, this cheesecake quartet is a reliable way to make the everyday feel special.