In Over Their Heads: History’s Most Underqualified People in Power - History Collection

2. Sarah Palin: Alaska to the National Stage

Sarah Palin’s meteoric journey from Wasilla mayor to Governor of Alaska surprised many, but her leap to the 2008 Republican vice-presidential ticket was even more startling. Her limited national and foreign policy experience became a lightning rod for debate, raising questions about what truly qualifies someone for high office. Palin’s candidacy ignited fierce discussions about experience versus charisma, forever altering the conversation about political readiness in America.

3. Nicholas II: The Unprepared Last Tsar

Nicholas II ascended the Russian throne in 1894, yet he was woefully unprepared for the immense responsibilities of ruling a vast, unstable empire. His lack of training and political acumen left him indecisive during critical moments, especially as Russia faced war and revolution. Unable to enact reforms or inspire confidence, Nicholas’s reign ended in the upheaval of the Russian Revolution and the collapse of the Romanov dynasty.

4. George W. Bush: From Governor to Global Crisis

When George W. Bush moved from Texas governor to U.S. President, he faced a world stage with limited foreign policy experience. The sudden test of 9/11 and the launch of the Iraq War put his leadership under intense scrutiny. Critics argued that Bush’s inexperience contributed to missteps, particularly in international diplomacy and conflict management, fueling debates about the necessity of expertise at the highest level.

5. Louis XVI: Ill-Prepared Monarch of France

Ascending the French throne at just twenty, Louis XVI faced an overwhelming financial crisis and a restless populace. He lacked the political insight and decisiveness needed to navigate these turbulent times. Louis’s hesitancy and poor counsel led to mounting unrest, ultimately culminating in the French Revolution and his execution. His reign stands as a powerful reminder of the risks when the unprepared are tasked with steering a nation through crisis.

6. Andrew Johnson: The Accidental President

After Abraham Lincoln’s assassination, Andrew Johnson—a Southern Democrat with minimal formal education and little national support—found himself unexpectedly leading a fractured nation. His lack of expertise and political isolation became painfully clear during the volatile Reconstruction era. Johnson’s controversial decisions and inability to unite Congress or the public led to his impeachment, marking one of the most turbulent episodes in American presidential history.

7. Commodus: Gladiator Emperor

Commodus inherited the Roman Empire at just eighteen, but his lack of interest in actual governance quickly became apparent. Instead of ruling, he preferred the spectacle of gladiatorial combat, even participating in the arena himself. His neglect of state affairs and obsession with personal glory created widespread political instability and corruption. Commodus’s reign is a vivid example of what happens when power falls to those more fascinated by entertainment than effective leadership.

8. Kim Jong-un: Heir Apparent with No Experience

When Kim Jong-un unexpectedly became Supreme Leader of North Korea in 2011, the world was stunned by his youth and lack of experience. With minimal political or military background, he was thrust into one of the most secretive and dangerous regimes on earth. His rapid consolidation of power and unpredictable policies quickly made headlines, fueling widespread concerns about stability and his preparedness to rule.

9. Ivan VI: The Baby Emperor

Few rulers embody underqualification more than Ivan VI of Russia, crowned emperor as an infant in 1740. Helpless and incapable of any real governance, Ivan’s reign was manipulated by regents and swiftly ended within months. His tragic fate—imprisonment for most of his short life—serves as a stark reminder of the perils of placing power in the hands of those utterly unprepared, even through no fault of their own.

10. Warren G. Harding: Unprepared for the Presidency

Warren G. Harding entered the White House with modest political experience and little background in national administration. His presidency was soon marred by scandals, most notoriously the Teapot Dome affair, exposing deep flaws in his leadership and judgment. Harding’s inability to control his cabinet or navigate Washington politics has made his tenure a classic warning about the risks of electing those unready for the nation’s highest office.

11. Manuel Noriega: Military Man Turned Dictator

Manuel Noriega rose through Panama’s military ranks but struggled when it came to governing a nation. His lack of political skill translated into a regime marked by corruption, repression, and instability. Noriega’s mismanagement and criminal activities eventually provoked a U.S. military intervention, ending his rule in disgrace. His story highlights the dangers of assuming that military prowess alone qualifies someone for the complex challenges of national leadership.

12. Emperor Puyi: The Child Ruler of China

Puyi was crowned as China’s last emperor at just two years old, thrust into power with no ability to lead. Throughout his tumultuous life, he was manipulated by powerful factions—first as a puppet monarch, then as a figurehead for foreign interests. Puyi’s reign and later experiences underscore the vulnerabilities and dangers of placing authority in the hands of the unprepared, especially in times of national upheaval.

13. Idi Amin: From Army Cook to President

Idi Amin began his career as an army cook, with no political experience or formal education. Yet, through a military coup, he seized control of Uganda and ruled with brutal, unpredictable force. Amin’s lack of understanding of governance led to economic collapse, widespread atrocities, and mass exile, leaving a grim legacy. His story remains a stark warning about the catastrophic consequences when unqualified individuals attain unchecked power.

14. Empress Matilda: Thrust into Civil War

When Empress Matilda was named heir to the English throne, her limited experience and lack of political support became glaringly apparent. Her claim sparked a brutal civil war—known as The Anarchy—plunging England into years of instability and violence. Matilda’s struggle to assert authority demonstrates how inadequate preparation and uncertain succession can unleash chaos, altering a nation’s fate for generations.

15. Jean-Bédel Bokassa: Self-Crowned Emperor

Jean-Bédel Bokassa rose from military officer to president, then declared himself emperor of the Central African Republic. His reign was notorious for extravagant ceremonies, rampant corruption, and egregious human rights abuses, all fueled by a profound lack of governing ability. Bokassa’s obsession with self-glorification and disregard for his people’s well-being turned his regime into an international scandal, showcasing the dangers of unchecked, inexperienced rule.

16. Charles II of Spain: The Inbred King

Charles II of Spain inherited the throne deeply affected by generations of Habsburg inbreeding, resulting in profound physical and mental disabilities. He struggled to govern, often manipulated by courtiers, and was incapable of producing an heir or managing the empire’s affairs. Charles’s tragic reign hastened the collapse of the Spanish Habsburg dynasty, illustrating how unfit rulers—through no fault of their own—can accelerate national decline.

17. Ferdinand Marcos Jr.: Dynastic Succession

Ferdinand Marcos Jr., son of the infamous Philippine dictator, rose to the nation’s highest office amid concerns over his qualifications and experience. Critics argue that his ascent relied heavily on family legacy rather than proven competence or leadership skills. His presidency has reignited debates about dynastic politics and the risks of prioritizing heritage over ability in governing a complex nation.

18. Edward VIII: Abdication and Inexperience

Edward VIII’s time as king of the United Kingdom was remarkably short, plagued by personal indecision and a lack of dedication to royal duties. His controversial relationship with Wallis Simpson and his ultimate abdication exposed his unpreparedness for the demands of monarchy. Edward’s reign stands as a prime example of how personal priorities and inexperience can undermine even the most established institutions.

19. Paul Deschanel: The Sleepwalking President

Paul Deschanel’s presidency is a fitting conclusion to this list of ill-prepared leaders. His brief time in office was overshadowed by eccentric behavior—including famously falling from a train while sleepwalking—and frequent public mishaps. Deschanel’s struggles made clear he was unsuited for the pressures of high office, ultimately leading to his resignation. These stories remind us that leadership demands more than titles or lineage—it requires true readiness and resilience. As history shows, societies must scrutinize those in power, learning from the past to safeguard the future.