Twisted by Time: The Real Lives of 10 Misjudged Medieval Icons - History Collection

2. Richard III: The Villain or Victim?

Richard III’s legacy has long been overshadowed by Shakespeare’s infamous depiction of him as a ruthless, deformed usurper. Yet recent scholarship and the dramatic discovery of his remains in Leicester have painted a more complex portrait. Historians now highlight his legal reforms and loyalty to his supporters, suggesting he was more a victim of Tudor propaganda than true villain. Richard’s story is a striking reminder of how easily history can be shaped by those who write it.

3. Eleanor of Aquitaine: Beyond Scandal

Eleanor of Aquitaine is frequently remembered for tales of scandal and intrigue, but this focus obscures her remarkable influence as a political powerhouse. As queen of both France and England, Eleanor played a pivotal role in European diplomacy, patronized the arts, and championed legal reforms. Her strategic alliances and cultural initiatives helped shape the medieval world. Modern historians recognize her not just as a controversial figure, but as one of the era’s most intelligent and influential women, whose true legacy extends far beyond gossip and rumor.

4. Vlad the Impaler: Bloodthirsty or Besieged?

Vlad III, better known as Vlad the Impaler, is often conflated with the fictional Dracula, cementing a legacy of horror and cruelty. However, his brutal reputation in Western Europe was shaped by political adversaries and propaganda during a time of relentless conflict with the Ottoman Empire. In his homeland, Vlad is remembered as a defender who used fear as a weapon of survival. His real story is far more nuanced than the monstrous myth that persists in popular culture.

5. Hildegard of Bingen: Mystic or Scientist?

Hildegard of Bingen is often pigeonholed as simply a mystic and visionary, but her legacy reaches far beyond spiritual revelations. She was a prolific composer, a pioneering writer on natural history, and a medical innovator whose remedies and holistic approach were centuries ahead of her time. Modern scholarship increasingly recognizes Hildegard as one of the earliest female scientists in Europe. Her life’s work reflects a blend of faith, scientific inquiry, and creativity—challenging the limits of medieval thought and our modern assumptions about her role.

6. Saladin: Chivalrous Enemy

In Western tales, Saladin is often cast as a ruthless adversary of the Crusaders, but this image is far from complete. Contemporary chroniclers and even his Christian foes acknowledged Saladin’s remarkable diplomacy and generosity. He famously spared civilians during the conquest of Jerusalem and exchanged gifts with Richard the Lionheart. Saladin’s legacy endures as a model of magnanimity and statesmanship—a leader who won respect on both sides of the conflict and whose story proves that honor could exist even in the fiercest of wars.

7. William Wallace: Freedom Fighter or Outlaw?

William Wallace’s image has been shaped by legend and Hollywood myth, most notably through the film “Braveheart.” While he’s often lionized as a fearless freedom fighter, English sources depicted him as a ruthless outlaw. Historical records show that Wallace was a skilled tactician whose leadership challenged English dominance in Scotland. His motivations were complex, rooted in both personal loss and national pride. The real Wallace occupies a space between myth and reality—a figure driven by conviction, not just the sword or the stories told about him.

8. Isabella of France: She-Wolf or Shrewd Diplomat?

Dubbed the “She-Wolf of France”, Isabella’s legacy is clouded by tales of betrayal and ambition. Yet, beneath this fierce reputation lies a woman of impressive diplomatic acumen and leadership. During England’s 14th-century crises, Isabella skillfully navigated political upheaval, engineering the deposition of Edward II and securing the throne for her son. Modern historians acknowledge her as a shrewd strategist who played a pivotal role in shaping England’s monarchy—far more than the villainess of traditional accounts.

9. Thomas Becket: Saint or Schemer?

Thomas Becket is celebrated as a martyr and saint, but this sanctified image often hides his complex role as a political operator. Becket’s dramatic conflict with King Henry II was not just a matter of faith, but a struggle for power between the church and the crown. He was known for his ambition and shrewdness, adeptly navigating court politics. While his murder shocked Europe and cemented his sainthood, the broader context reveals a man deeply engaged in the realpolitik of medieval England.

10. Genghis Khan: Barbarian or Nation Builder?

Genghis Khan is often condemned in the West as a barbaric conqueror, yet this view ignores his far-reaching achievements. He unified warring tribes, introduced progressive legal codes, and fostered religious tolerance across his vast empire. Under his rule, the Silk Road flourished, enabling cultural exchange and global trade on an unprecedented scale. Historians now recognize Genghis Khan as a transformative leader whose legacy stretches far beyond conquest—shaping the world in ways that still resonate today.