15 Major Scandals That Rocked The British Monarchy Through History

4. Queen Caroline’s Public Trial (1820)

In 1820, King George IV initiated a public trial against his estranged wife, Queen Caroline, aiming to dissolve their marriage and strip her of her title. The government introduced the Pains and Penalties Bill, alleging that Caroline had committed adultery with her Italian servant, Bartolomeo Pergami. The House of Lords conducted hearings, effectively a public trial, where evidence was presented, and Caroline’s defense team cross-examined witnesses. Despite the sensational nature of the proceedings, the bill faced significant public opposition, and the government withdrew it before it could pass through the House of Commons. Caroline remained married to George IV until her death in 1821. For more detailed information, you can refer to the National Portrait Gallery’s coverage on the Trial of Queen Caroline. (npg.org.uk)

5. The Affair of Queen Victoria’s Servant (Brown Affair)

Following the death of her husband, Prince Albert, in 1861, Queen Victoria formed a close relationship with her Scottish servant, John Brown. Their companionship led to public speculation and court gossip, with some suggesting a romantic involvement. Contemporary accounts describe their interactions as remarkably intimate, with Victoria’s physician recording flirtatious exchanges involving skirt-lifting, while the monarch herself wrote of regarding Brown with ‘an everlasting love’. (britbrief.co.uk) Despite the rumors, no definitive evidence of a romantic relationship has been found. For more detailed information, you can refer to Historic UK’s coverage on Queen Victoria and John Brown. (history.co.uk)

6. Prince Andrew’s Association with Jeffrey Epstein

Prince Andrew faced intense scrutiny for his connections to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, leading to legal battles, public outrage, and loss of royal duties. In 2019, Virginia Giuffre accused Prince Andrew of sexual assault, a claim he has consistently denied. The controversy surrounding these allegations resulted in Prince Andrew stepping back from public royal duties and facing significant public and media criticism. For more detailed information, you can refer to the BBC News coverage on Prince Andrew’s association with Jeffrey Epstein. (bbc.com)

7. The Princess Margaret-Peter Townsend Romance

Princess Margaret’s romantic involvement with Group Captain Peter Townsend, a divorced RAF officer, in the 1950s, challenged royal protocols and public expectations. Their relationship faced opposition due to the Church of England’s teachings on divorce and the Royal Marriages Act of 1772, which required the monarch’s consent for royal marriages. Despite public sympathy, Margaret chose duty over love, ending the engagement to maintain her royal duties and position in the line of succession. For more detailed information, you can refer to The Guardian’s coverage on Princess Margaret and Peter Townsend. (theguardian.com)

8. Princess Diana’s Tell-All Interview (1995)

9. The ‘Trooping the Colour’ Intruder (1982)

In 1982, Michael Fagan, an unemployed Londoner, managed to breach Buckingham Palace’s security and entered Queen Elizabeth II’s bedroom. He climbed over the palace’s perimeter wall, scaled a drainpipe, and accessed the building through an unlocked window. Once inside, Fagan wandered the palace corridors, triggering alarms that were dismissed as faulty by security personnel. He eventually reached the Queen’s private apartments and disturbed her sleep by drawing back the curtains. The Queen, startled, used her bedside alarm to summon help, but it went unanswered due to a changeover in security shifts. She then called the palace switchboard, and after a delay, a footman arrived, leading Fagan into a pantry where he was offered a drink until police arrived to arrest him. The incident exposed significant lapses in palace security protocols. Fagan was not charged with trespassing, as it was a civil offense at the time, but was charged with theft for taking a bottle of wine during his first intrusion; however, the charges were dropped after he was committed for psychiatric evaluation. (biography.com).

10. The Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Exit (Megxit)

In January 2020, Prince Harry and Meghan Markle announced their decision to step back as senior members of the British royal family, aiming to achieve financial independence and divide their time between the UK and North America. This move, often referred to as “Megxit,” led to significant public and media scrutiny, as well as debates about royal duties and institutional racism. For more detailed information, you can refer to CNN’s coverage on Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s exit. (cnn.com)

11. The Affair and Death of Thomas Culpeper

In 1541, Thomas Culpeper, a gentleman of the Privy Chamber, was implicated in an alleged affair with Queen Catherine Howard, Henry VIII’s fifth wife. Catherine, who had been married to Henry for just over a year, was accused of engaging in secret meetings with Culpeper, which were considered treasonous. Under interrogation, Culpeper admitted to intending to have sexual relations with the Queen, though he denied any actual misconduct. Both Culpeper and Francis Dereham, another man associated with Catherine, were tried for treason and executed on December 10, 1541. Culpeper was beheaded, while Dereham was hanged, drawn, and quartered. Their heads were displayed on London Bridge as a warning to others. Catherine Howard was arrested and stripped of her title as Queen in November 1541. She was executed on February 13, 1542, at the Tower of London. Reports suggest that she faced her death with dignity, acknowledging her guilt and expressing remorse. (hrp.org.uk) The affair and subsequent executions highlighted the dangers of courtly intrigue and the severe consequences of infidelity within the Tudor monarchy.

12. The Scandal of ‘Camillagate’ (1993)

In 1993, an intimate phone conversation between Prince Charles and Camilla Parker Bowles was leaked to the press, revealing the depth of their extramarital relationship. The conversation, which included suggestive remarks and expressions of affection, was recorded in 1989 and published in the tabloids, causing public outrage and intensifying scrutiny of the royal marriage. The scandal, known as ‘Camillagate,’ significantly damaged the reputations of both Charles and Diana, leading to increased media attention and public debate over the state of their relationship. For more detailed information, you can refer to the New York Times’ coverage on the transcript of Charles’ phone call. (nytimes.com)

13. Lord Porchester and Queen Elizabeth II Rumors

Speculation has long surrounded the close friendship between Queen Elizabeth II and Lord Henry Porchester, known as “Porchie,” who served as her racing manager and confidant. Their shared passion for horses and frequent public appearances together led to unfounded rumors about a romantic relationship. However, both the Queen and Lord Porchester consistently denied these claims, emphasizing their deep, platonic bond. Their enduring friendship was rooted in mutual respect and a shared love for equestrian pursuits. (townandcountrymag.com)

14. The ‘Porcelain Throne’ Letters – Prince Charles Black Spider Memos

In 2015, a decade-long legal battle culminated in the publication of 27 letters, known as the “black spider memos,” written by Prince Charles to British government ministers between 2004 and 2005. These letters revealed the Prince of Wales’s direct lobbying on various issues, including military equipment, alternative medicine, and environmental policies. The release sparked debates about the monarchy’s political neutrality and the extent of the heir’s influence on government affairs. For more detailed information, you can refer to The Guardian’s coverage on the publication of Prince Charles’s black spider memos. (theguardian.com)

15. The Death of Lord Mountbatten (1979)

In 1979, Lord Louis Mountbatten, Prince Philip’s uncle and a beloved figure within the British royal family, was assassinated by the Provisional Irish Republican Army (IRA). The attack occurred when a bomb planted on his fishing boat exploded off the coast of County Sligo, Ireland, resulting in Mountbatten’s death and the deaths of three others. This tragic event shocked the nation and underscored the monarchy’s vulnerability to political violence. For more detailed information, you can refer to the BBC News coverage on the death of Lord Mountbatten. (bbc.com)

Conclusion

Throughout its history, the British monarchy has faced numerous scandals that have tested its resilience and adaptability. From the abdication crisis of Edward VIII to the more recent controversies involving Prince Andrew, each incident has challenged the institution’s image and public perception. These events have prompted the royal family to evolve, striving to maintain relevance and trust in a changing world. The monarchy’s ability to navigate these challenges continues to shape its role in modern society. (apnews.com)