Ina Garten’s Must-Try Cupcake Box Is Here for the Holidays—and It’s Selling Out Fast

Published on December 17, 2025

The original Barefoot Contessa store may have closed its doors two decades ago, but its signature goodies still live on. Ina Garten reopened her shop via Goldbelly to ship her favorite recipes all across the country, and fans couldn’t be more grateful.

At Goldbelly, Garten’s coconut cupcakes are one of her most popular offerings—alongside her incredibly moist chocolate cupcakes. For the holidays, Garten created a cupcake combo box that offers the best of both worlds. Each box features five coconut cupcakes and four chocolate cupcakes.

The box of nine jumbo cupcakes is definitely an Ina Garten-approved hosting gift, and they’re also guaranteed to be the star of your next dinner party. Now, it’s your turn to get your hands on a box before they sell out for the season. 

Ina's Signature Cupcakes Combo - 9 Pack

What's Inside

Ina Garten’s iconic Coconut Cake recipe has rave reviews, and many home cooks who have tried it say it’s their new go-to dessert recipe. Thanks to Goldbelly, you can now enjoy it in cupcake form without spending any time in the kitchen. Each coconut cake cupcake has the same white cake base you’ll find in Garten’s original recipe. Then, the cupcakes are topped with a rich cream cheese frosting before being covered in sweet coconut flakes. 

Don’t think Garten would let you miss out on her chocolate cake, either. Her Beatty’s Chocolate Cake recipe comes out on top for anyone who’s tried it—on Food Network’s website, itRelated

While her Beatty's Chocolate Cake recipe uses chocolate frosting, Garten put a little spin on the frosting for her chocolate cupcakes. They each come with a fluffy vanilla frosting enriched with cream cheese. The tart-and-sweet frosting helps to cut through that deliciously rich chocolate cake base. 

If you were wondering just how jumbo a jumbo cupcake is, Goldbelly says that they measure about 4 inches. Each cupcake comes with an adorable blue label, complete with a note in Garten’s handwriting. All nine cupcakes will arrive in a blue striped “Barefoot Contessa” box that’s ready to gift…as long as you can resist trying one yourself, first.

Ordering and Storing the Cupcakes

A box of Garten’s signature cupcakes is available through the Goldbelly website, and after ordering, they typically arrive within a couple of business days. If you’re planning on gifting these cupcakes, you can have them shipped straight to the recipient’s doorstep; alternatively, let them schedule their own cupcake delivery by sending them a preview of their cupcake gift via email. 

Goldbelly claims that this box serves nine people, but we’re pretty sure you’ll want to keep these cupcakes to yourself. Store them in the fridge for up to five days or the freezer for up to three months. But let’s be honest—they’re not going to be around that long.