The Bottom-Shelf Bourbon Worth Keeping On Your Shelf

Catherine Falls Commercial/Getty Images

If someone tried to offer you bottom-shelf bourbon, you may politely decline. After all, it's the darker liquors that are said to give a more brutal hangover, and it's simply not worth it if you're sipping on something cheap. Before you say "No, thank you", know that not all budget bourbons are created equal. Evan Williams, named after the man who established the first commercial distillery in Kentucky in 1783, is proof of that.

Bottled in Bardstown, Kentucky by Heaven Hill Distillery, this no-frills Kentucky straight bourbon has earned its place as one of the best-selling whiskey brands in the country. Globally, it is the second-best-selling brand. As a Kentucky straight bourbon, there are some strict production rules for quality control, like it must be produced in the state, aged in new, charred oak barrels for at least two years, and not contain the addition of flavorings or colors. Evan Williams has been aged for a minimum of four years, which results in a smooth and slightly sweet profile with notes of smoky oak, brown sugar, vanilla, caramel, and just a hint of spice. 

At 86 proof (Kentucky straight bourbon must be a minimum of 80 proof), it's strong enough to hold up in cocktails but can also be sipped on. Some whiskey drinkers may dismiss it for its $13 to $18 price tag or delegated spot on the bottom shelf, but consider that just another advantage.

Masyna/Shutterstock

One of Evan Williams' biggest strengths is its versatility. There are plenty of mixing options besides a bourbon and coke, and this bottle is an easy pick for making a wide range of cocktails, including the classics like an old fashioned or whiskey sour. Its caramel notes also play nicely in a Kentucky mule, while the reasonable price means you won't flinch at using a generous pour. On Heaven Hill's website, the recommended cocktail for Evan Williams is a mint julep, while the Evan Williams' website provides a Manhattan recipe with the bourbon, alongside sweet vermouth and bitters.

For something simple at the end of a long day, a generous pour can be served over a large ice cube and enjoyed neat. Without ice, it can be served up in a Glencairn glass and left to breathe before sipping on it. It may not beat a top-shelf celebration bottle, but it's certainly a worthy weekend staple.

Evan Williams bourbon doesn't try too hard, yet it reliably delivers without breaking the bank; plus, it's widely available in bars and liquor stores. It's worth having a bottle on hand for any occasion or mixed drink, and if you order it out at a bar, you won't be disappointed. You may even be inspired to learn about other underrated bourbon brands to keep stocked.