We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Because buying two gifts is overrated.

Published on October 1, 2025

Credit:

Better Homes & Gardens

Whether you’re going to an engagement party or hunting for the best housewarming gift, buying one present that works for a couple can be tough. Especially if they have different tastes or interests, finding something that hits the sweet spot—and earns you street cred with both of them—takes some major thought. Not sure where to start? That's what I’m here for. 

I did some digging—and reached out to our lovely team of Better Homes & Gardens editors—for the best gifts for couples they’ve ever given or received. Since different occasions call for different gifts, I’ve broken it down into categories: engagement, housewarming, new parents, and, of course, pet parents. Here are my top picks, including cozy throw blankets, personalized wall decor,  kitchenware, and more.

Best Engagement Gifts

Love is in the air, and the right engagement gifts can make it even sweeter. I’m obsessed with the Williams Sonoma Dainty Heart Mini Bottle—a customized keepsake so cute, they’ll never want to drink it. Choose from over 20 types of wine (including some non-alcoholic options) and add your design. They can keep it cool in this marble wine chiller, which is just as functional as it is beautiful. 

For an elegant engagement gift, these crystal champagne flutesscream luxury. Personalize them with a name or monogram for an extra-special touch. And you can’t go wrong with the Kate Spade Take the Cake Picture Frame, perfect for displaying their favorite photos and memories.

Best Housewarming Gifts

What better way to celebrate a new home with fresh wall art? This personalized house portrait is a must. Just upload a photo of their new place, choose a size, and add custom text to make it theirs. 

Speaking of personalized gifts, the Hill House Home Mini Pillowcase is another great choice. With tons of patterns to choose from—and even the option to add a monogram—it’s a cute addition to any bed, sofa, or chair. 

And simply put: this Cozy Earth sheet set is unreal. I have it on my own bed and always put it right back on after laundry day. Pair it with the Lola Blanket (one of the softest I’ve ever felt), and they’ll never want to get off their couch.

Best Gifts for New Parents

While gift cards are often considered “impersonal,” I can vouch that an Uber Eats one is foolproof. New parents will love ordering in that Chinese food they’ve been craving for months—or even stocking up on groceries—without having to leave the house. Tack on the Ember Temperature Control Smart Mug 2, and they’ll actually be able to enjoy a hot cup of coffee or tea (even if they’re a slow sipper). 

New parents only sleep as well as their newborns do, so Hatch’s portable sound machine is a win for everyone. They can choose from 10 relaxing sounds (ocean waves are my personal favorite), and the clip-on design makes it super easy to bring it on the go. 

Caraa’s baby bag is another fan favorite—and the brand just released new fall-inspired colors. It can fit all the essentials (diapers, wipes, bottles, clothing, toys). And it looks sleek enough to walk around with.

Best Gifts for Pet Parents

Pet parents love one thing: showing off their furry friends. That’s why this cute portrait from West & Willow is the perfect pick—it’s totally display-worthy and gives them a great excuse to gush about their pet.  

To keep their pup entertained (and buy themselves a little breathing room), go with the Chewffon Interactive Spinning Puppy Puzzle. Pro tip: If they add some peanut butter or cottage cheese, their pet will be occupied for longer. And once their dog is finally worn out, they’ll love chilling in their throne—aka the UnHide Floof Donut Pet Bed.

Last but not least: the Furbo 360-Degree Dog Camera is every pet owner’s dream. The app lets them watch, talk to, and even toss treats to their dog anytime, anywhere.

Who We Are

Jamie Fischer is a writer for Better Homes and Gardens. With over two years of experience creating gift guides, she’s self-proclaimed gifting expert. For this list, she pulled together her personal faves, plus product recs from her fellow editors.