American Icons, Hidden Legacies: U.S. Heroes With Slaveholding Pasts - History Collection

2. Thomas Jefferson

Thomas Jefferson, author of the Declaration of Independence, famously proclaimed that “all men are created equal.” Yet at his Monticello plantation, he enslaved more than 600 people over his lifetime. Jefferson’s advocacy for liberty starkly conflicts with his reliance on enslaved labor and his failure to free most of those he held in bondage. Unlike George Washington, Jefferson did not provide for the emancipation of his enslaved workers in his will. Monticello explores this enduring contradiction at the heart of his legacy.

3. James Madison

Often hailed as the “Father of the Constitution,” James Madison played a pivotal role in defining American democracy. Yet, at his Montpelier estate, Madison was also a lifelong slaveholder, relying on the forced labor of numerous men, women, and children. His experience as a plantation owner influenced his political stances, including compromises that protected slavery in the founding documents. The complexity of Madison’s legacy is explored in depth at Montpelier.

4. Andrew Jackson

Andrew Jackson, the seventh president, is remembered for his populist appeal and military triumphs, but his legacy is deeply marred by his ownership of hundreds of enslaved people at The Hermitage. Jackson not only profited from slavery but also enforced policies that devastated both enslaved Africans and Indigenous peoples, including the infamous Indian Removal Act. The full scope of Jackson’s involvement with slavery and his impact on marginalized communities is documented by The Hermitage.

5. James Monroe

James Monroe, the fifth president, presided over an era of national expansion while also managing enslaved workers at his Highland estate. His public statements about slavery were often nuanced, at times expressing discomfort but ultimately supporting policies that perpetuated the institution. Monroe’s actions and words reflect the era’s complexities and contradictions, as explored by James Monroe’s Highland, revealing another layer to the legacy of American leadership.

6. Zachary Taylor

Zachary Taylor, renowned for his military leadership and brief presidency, was also one of the nation’s largest slaveholders. His extensive ownership of enslaved people directly influenced his political decisions and perspectives, especially during debates over slavery’s expansion into new territories. Taylor’s legacy is a compelling example of how personal interests and public policy were often intertwined for America’s early leaders. The White House Historical Association offers further insight into Taylor’s complicated history.

7. John Tyler

John Tyler, the tenth president, presided over Sherwood Forest, where many enslaved people lived and worked. Throughout his political career, Tyler was a staunch opponent of abolitionist movements, defending slavery as integral to the Southern economy and society. His policies and personal choices reflected a commitment to preserving slavery, further illuminating the contradictions in the legacy of early American leaders. More about Tyler’s views and actions can be found at the National Park Service.

8. Martin Van Buren

Martin Van Buren began his adult life as a slave owner in New York, a state where slavery was gradually being abolished. As president and later as a political leader, Van Buren often navigated the era’s contentious slavery debates, reflecting the North’s shifting attitudes. His evolving positions illustrate the nation’s transition and the personal contradictions of its leaders. For more, see Encyclopedia Britannica.

9. Benjamin Franklin

Benjamin Franklin’s relationship with slavery evolved dramatically over his lifetime. While he once owned enslaved people, Franklin ultimately became a passionate advocate for abolition, making him stand apart from many of his peers. Late in life, he led anti-slavery initiatives and petitioned Congress to end the institution. His transformation is detailed by Smithsonian Magazine, showing how change was possible, even for America’s founding icons.

10. Francis Scott Key

Francis Scott Key, celebrated for penning “The Star-Spangled Banner,” also had a complicated relationship with slavery. Key was a slaveholder and, as a lawyer, represented both enslaved and free Black Americans in court, resulting in a mixed legacy. While he stood as a national symbol, his actions and beliefs reflect the era’s contradictions. Smithsonian Magazine explores the darker side of Key’s story and its connection to American history.

11. Sam Houston

Sam Houston, renowned for his pivotal role in Texas’s fight for independence, was also a slaveholder, reflecting the contradictions of his era. Despite owning enslaved people, Houston often advocated moderation on the issue of slavery and resisted some of the most extreme pro-slavery measures. His nuanced positions are explored by the Texas State Historical Association, revealing the complexities of Houston’s legacy as both a leader and a man of his time.

12. Ulysses S. Grant

Ulysses S. Grant is best remembered as the general who led the Union Army to victory and later as a president fighting for Reconstruction and civil rights. Yet, early in his marriage, Grant briefly owned an enslaved person through his wife’s family. This stark contrast between his personal history and his later leadership is explored by the National Park Service, highlighting how personal legacies can evolve in unexpected ways.

13. Patrick Henry

Patrick Henry remains immortalized for his impassioned cry, “Give me liberty, or give me death!” Yet, like many of his contemporaries, he continued to rely on the labor of enslaved people throughout his life. This fundamental contradiction between his ideals and actions underscores the paradoxes at the heart of the American Revolution. More about Henry’s complex legacy can be found at Encyclopedia Virginia.

14. John Hancock

John Hancock’s bold signature on the Declaration of Independence stands as a symbol of American freedom. However, Hancock and his family were also slaveholders, adding a layer of complexity and contradiction to his legacy. This duality raises enduring questions about the meaning of liberty and the realities of hypocrisy among the Founders. The Boston Globe explores these tensions in depth.

15. James Polk

James Polk, the eleventh president, presided over a period of dramatic territorial expansion for the United States. Polk owned a large plantation in Mississippi, where enslaved people did the grueling work that supported his wealth and lifestyle. His expansionist policies, including the annexation of Texas and the Mexican-American War, significantly increased the number of enslaved people in new American territories. The White House Historical Association discusses Polk’s life and legacy in detail.